Tag Archives: burger

Bürger Review

Mar 27, 2007 – 9:19 PM

Here is what Reviewer #3 submitted in his review of the Bürger CPD submission (I’ve taken down the draft review.) He regrets agreeing to do the review (for reasons that will become clear). Even though Reviewer #3 has much goodwill towards Bürger, he is rather a stickler for detail and it seems rather unfair that […]

By Steve McIntyre | Posted in MBH98, Statistics | Comments (61)

Jean S on Rutherford et al 2005

Jul 10, 2006 – 1:48 PM

Jean S has sent the following longer contribution on Rutherford et al 2005. I always appreciate Jean S’s thoughtful comments (which is no secret to readers here). So enjoy. JeanS: Now since the review of Burger and Cubash [BC06 here after] put Rutherford (2005) [R05] back on the table, there is an issue to which […]

By Steve McIntyre | Posted in RegEM | Also tagged , , | Comments (46)

Bürger and Cubasch Discussion

Jul 8, 2006 – 1:28 PM

I hope that you are following the lively discussion about Burger and Cubasch at Climates of the Past here , where Mann aka Anonymous Referee #2 is carrying on in a quite extraodinary way. I’ll probably try to weigh in over there at some point. The dialogue has exploded fairly quickly and I’ve collated some […]

By Steve McIntyre | Posted in Replication, Spurious | Also tagged | Comments (147)

Bürger and Cubasch

Jan 26, 2006 – 2:54 PM

I quickly mentioned BàƒÆ’à‚⻲ger and Cubasch [2005] which was published in December and meant to post up some further comments at the time, but forgot to do so. I was reminded of this by the question of a reader at Daily Kos . Let me mention first that BàƒÆ’à‚⻲ger and Cubasch is a really interesting […]

By Steve McIntyre | Posted in MBH98 | Also tagged | Comments (44)
Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 429 other followers