Tag Archives: carvin

One of Carvin’s Gaffes

Jan 2, 2015 – 7:29 PM

In some recent posts, I’ve observed that Carvin made a couple of astonishing gaffes in his oral argument.  In today’s post, I’ll comment on the worst one.  First, I’ll report the exchange without context.  I presume that 99.99% of Climate Audit readers will spot the gaffe immediately.  Read and react to Carvin’s words before reading […]

By Stephen McIntyre | Posted in Uncategorized | Also tagged , , | Comments (159)

Oral Argument 2: EPA on “Fraud” Allegations

Jan 1, 2015 – 3:47 PM

Towards the end of Carvin’s mostly cringeworthy rebuttal,  he seemed to score on EPA’s rejection of complaints against Mann’s own defamatory accusations of “scientific fraud”.  EPA had found that Mann’s use of the term “fraud” meant no more than he believed the articles to be “scientifically flawed” and that, in such circumstances, Mann’s language was […]

By Stephen McIntyre | Posted in Uncategorized | Also tagged , , | Comments (48)

Oral Argument 1: Context

Dec 22, 2014 – 5:04 PM

I have an audio copy of the oral argument in Mann v Steyn, which I’ve posted up (see link at the end of this post). One of things often under-estimated by those readers (especially at WUWT) who are bloodthirsty for litigation as a means of settling scores is that it’s not easy for litigation lawyers to […]

By Stephen McIntyre | Posted in Uncategorized | Also tagged , , , | Comments (214)