Tag Archives: swindle

Swindle and the IPCC TAR Spaghetti Graph

May 15, 2007 – 4:55 PM

Our text for today remains: If a practising scientist selected a 1987 data set over more recent versions, failed to cite it correctly, altered the appearance of the data without a clear explanation and didn’t include the data from the last 20 years then I think we’d all be asking serious questions about their professionalism. […]

By Stephen McIntyre | Posted in IPCC, MBH98, TGGWS | Also tagged , , | Comments (64)

Swindle and the Stick

May 8, 2007 – 12:57 PM

The first complaint by RMS (and others) against Swindle seems to be about their handling of the Hockey Stick. A new complaint from someone at the University of Bristol includes a spaghetti graph, including MBH, saying that it shows that the newer reconstructions use “superior methods”, “supersede” the earlier results and that the old IPCC […]

By Stephen McIntyre | Posted in MBH98, TGGWS | Also tagged , , , | Comments (51)

Risk Management Solutions Ltd and the 37 Professors

May 3, 2007 – 2:51 PM

In the complaint about Swindle by Risk Management Solutions Ltd., endorsed by a gaggle of 37 professors, they allege that the Swindle graphic of 20th century claims in connection with 20th century temperature change contains the following misrepresentations: Measurements from meteorological stations that have been published by NASA and other agencies show that the there […]

By Stephen McIntyre | Posted in TGGWS | Also tagged | Comments (266)

The Swindle Complaint and Myles Allen

May 2, 2007 – 10:45 PM

Bob Ward, who you may remember as the author of various complaints from the U.K. Royal Society, is now employed at Risk Management Solutions Ltd. In his business capacity as Director, Global Science Networks, Risk Management Solutions Ltd., he has filed a complaint about Swindle under a section of the broadcasting code which states: “Views […]

By Stephen McIntyre | Posted in Archiving, News and Commentary, TGGWS | Also tagged | Comments (133)

Swindle and Inconvenient Divergence

Apr 30, 2007 – 1:51 PM

Climate scientists didn’t bother checking the Hockey Stick, but they are showing great diligence in going through The Great Global Warming Swindle. Nathan Rive (archive here) is the newest entrant; he has cross-checked one of the graphics in Swindle against the original graphic in Lassen and Friis-Christensen and found a discrepancy between the graphic and […]

By Stephen McIntyre | Posted in IPCC, TGGWS | Also tagged , | Comments (58)